Once on the island, we walked around the town, which is full of pedestrians, cyclists, and horse-drawn carriages. No cars or motorcycles are allowed on the island at all. Most of the island is State Park and it is very beautiful; there is clear blue water, white stones, and green trees. We ate on the porch overlooking the water at a place called Mary's Bistro. They grilled in front of you and the pulled pork sandwich was really good. We had a perfect view of a wedding from where we were sitting and we watched the say their vows. Then we rented a tandem bike and rode 10 miles around the circumference of the island.
Then we ate some Chocolate Mint fudge from Ryba's. We also stopped by the Robert Stuart House Museum which was donation only and it had a history of the island and information about Robert Stuart who was fur trading partners with John Jacob Astor (I was mainly interested because I knew of Astor from the Titanic; apparently the one from the Titanic was the fur trader's grandson). Harry's Old Time Photos was a worthwhile time from our trip; we got to dress up as mobster and a flapper.
After eating a flatbread pizza at Goodfellow's (an Italian Chop House) we changed into our formal attire and went to walk the grounds of the Grand Hotel. We were walking to the front when one of the bellhops opened a side door for us. He thought we were guests! Usually, you have to pay $10 admission to walk the grounds if you aren't registered. So we took the elevator and walked down the hallways where the rooms were. Then we found our way to the parlor where we chatted and then walked the porch. The hotel is very fancy and the employees are very nice.
We definitely had a very fun time and we only spent about $150 for both of us (gas not included)! We would recommend this for everyone to do at least once. The island is beautiful and very unique!